ABC · LiveNOW from Fox · updated 2026-09-22

Newslive Burden Lindsay Clancy's Attorney Asks Judge Proof to Question Holdout Juror

See how ABC and LiveNOW from Fox are framing this — we run every side, so you decide. News for humans, not bots: serious, civil discussion among real people, with the context and facts you need. Don't just watch: be on the air with your own video takes, polls and predictions.

ABC

“LINDSAY CLANCY'S ATTORNEY ASKS JUDGE TO INVESTIGATE LONE HOLDOUT JUROR”

covered 2026-09-22 ▶ Be on the air with ABC
LiveNOW from Fox

“LINDSAY CLANCY DEFENSE FILES MOTION TO DISMIS”

covered 2026-09-22 ▶ Be on the air with LiveNOW from Fox

Watch the moment

COURT TV

Neal K. Shah

Add your voice

Polls, predictions & fact-checks we ran live across networks — your take joins the running tally, compared across every network.

Questioning a holdout juror is extremely rare in U.S. courts!

Judges can question jurors refusing to deliberate in good faith — but it's delicate: too much pressure can violate a defendant's right to a fair jury. Trial attorneys like Austin parse exactly that line.

Before her 2023 arrest, Lindsay Clancy worked as a labor and delivery nurse at MGH

Clancy's attorney Kevin Reddington has defended killers for 40+ years.

Reddington, a Plymouth, MA-based attorney, is one of New England's most prominent criminal defense lawyers. He previously defended Neil Entwistle, convicted of murdering his wife and infant daughter in 2008.

The Yates case is the landmark precedent for postpartum psychosis defenses.

Andrea Yates, convicted in 2002 for drowning her 5 children, won a retrial in 2006 and was found not guilty by reason of insanity — a legal outcome the Clancy defense may be pursuing.

Topic poll · all networksWill Lindsay Clancy's motion to dismiss succeed in court?

  • Yes — postpartum defense wins 0%
  • No — case goes to full trial 0%
  • Partial — charges reduced 0%
  • Too early to call 0%

Be the first to weigh in

Topic poll · all networksWhat legally limits a juror from giving media interviews after a verdict?

  1. Federal Rule 606(b)
  2. A judge's post-trial order
  3. State bar ethics rules
  4. The 6th Amendment
Guess, then reveal the answer

A judge's post-trial order

…and 1 more when you're on the air.

The conversation

No comments yet — be the first to add your voice when you're on the air. Civil, moderated, bot-free.

LIVE ROOMS Rooms open during live coverage 2 channels ▾
ABC ▶ Be on the air LiveNOW from Fox ▶ Be on the air