ABC · LiveNOW from Fox · updated 5h ago

No Decision on Retrial in Lindsay Clancy Murder Cas

See how ABC and LiveNOW from Fox are framing this — we run every side, so you decide. News for humans, not bots: serious, civil discussion among real people, with the context and facts you need. Don't just watch: be on the air with your own video takes, polls and predictions.

EVERY NETWORK'S FRAMING

ABC

“DEFENSE ARGUES THERE IS NO EVIDENCE LINDSAY CLANCY ADMITTED TO KILLING HER KIDS”

covered 5h ago ▶ Be on the air with ABC
LiveNOW from Fox

“NO DECISION ON RETRIAL IN LINDSAY CLANCY MURDER CAS”

covered 5h ago ▶ Be on the air with LiveNOW from Fox

Watch the moment

Associated Press

COURT TV

Nate The Lawyer

Add your voice

Polls, predictions & fact-checks we ran live across networks — your take joins the running tally, compared across every network.

Neama Rahmani prosecuted federal cases before becoming a TV legal analyst.

Rahmani served as a federal prosecutor before founding West Coast Trial Lawyers. That courtroom experience — handling real criminal cases — is why networks turn to him to break down complex legal decisions like the Lindsay Clancy retrial question.

Topic poll · all networksShould insanity cases like Clancy's always use a split guilt/sanity trial?

  • Yes — two phases is fairer 0%
  • No — one trial is efficient 0%
  • Only when the judge allows it 0%
  • Depends on the evidence 0%

Be the first to weigh in

Topic poll · all networksHow many murder counts does Lindsay Clancy face in her retrial?

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 5
Guess, then reveal the answer

3

Bifurcated trials can cost roughly 2x a standard trial!

Two separate phases — guilt, then sanity — mean double the jury time, expert witnesses, and court costs. Judge Sullivan denied this structure in the Clancy case, keeping it as one combined proceeding.

Topic poll · all networksWill Patrick Clancy's 60 Minutes interview affect the retrial?

  • Yes — defense uses it in court 0%
  • Yes — to test his credibility 0%
  • No — courts bar media interviews 0%
  • No — Patrick isn't a key witness 0%

Be the first to weigh in

Topic poll · all networksShould postpartum psychosis be a full defense in murder cases?

  • Yes — it's a medical emergency 0%
  • Only with strict expert review 0%
  • No — accountability must stand 0%
  • Depends on severity of illness 0%

Be the first to weigh in

…and 2 more when you're on the air.

The conversation

No comments yet — be the first to add your voice when you're on the air. Civil, moderated, bot-free.

LIVE ROOMS Rooms open during live coverage 2 channels ▾
ABC ▶ Be on the air LiveNOW from Fox ▶ Be on the air