ABC · LiveNOW from Fox · updated 2026-10-09

Outrage Over Shooting by Ice in New York City

See how ABC and LiveNOW from Fox are framing this — we run every side, so you decide. News for humans, not bots: serious, civil discussion among real people, with the context and facts you need. Don't just watch: be on the air with your own video takes, polls and predictions.

EVERY NETWORK'S FRAMING

LiveNOW from Fox

“MAMDANI BLASTS ICE OVER SHOOTING IN NEW YORK CIT”

covered 2026-10-09 ▶ Be on the air with LiveNOW from Fox
ABC

“OUTRAGE OVER SHOOTING BY ICE IN NEW YORK CITY”

covered 2026-10-09 ▶ Be on the air with ABC

Watch the moment

Eyewitness News ABC7NY

CBS New York

CBS New York

Add your voice

Polls, predictions & fact-checks we ran live across networks — your take joins the running tally, compared across every network.

Topic poll · all networksBy federal policy, ICE agents must show what during arrests?

  1. A badge and credentials
  2. A written arrest warrant
  3. A Department of Justice ID
  4. A signed court order
Guess, then reveal the answer

A badge and credentials

Topic poll · all networksShould ICE agents use lethal force in immigration arrests?

  • Yes, as armed federal officers 0%
  • Only if directly threatened 0%
  • No — ICE is civil enforcement 0%
  • Too early to judge this case 0%

Be the first to weigh in

ICE's FY2024 budget topped $9.5 billion for immigration enforcement.

ICE's Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) — the unit conducting field arrests like the Marble Hill shooting — received ~$4.8B of that, funding agents, detention facilities, and deportations nationwide.

Topic poll · all networksShould ICE run operations in sanctuary cities?

  • Yes — federal law trumps local 0%
  • Only with local coordination 0%
  • No — cities set their own rules 0%
  • Depends on the specific target 0%

Be the first to weigh in

ICE spends roughly $150/day to detain each person in custody.

ICE's total annual budget tops $9.5 billion (FY2024). With an average daily detained population of ~37,000 people, detention costs alone account for billions — more than many mid-sized U.S. city budgets combined.

Topic poll · all networksWho should investigate when ICE agents fire their weapons?

  • NYPD — it's their jurisdiction 0%
  • DOJ — federal agents, fed probe 0%
  • An independent civilian board 0%
  • ICE internal affairs only 0%

Be the first to weigh in

…and 3 more when you're on the air.

The conversation

No comments yet — be the first to add your voice when you're on the air. Civil, moderated, bot-free.

LIVE ROOMS Rooms open during live coverage 2 channels ▾
ABC ▶ Be on the air LiveNOW from Fox ▶ Be on the air